How to Switch Loyalty Apps Without Losing Regulars

Loyalty guides

How to Switch Loyalty Apps Without Losing Your Regulars

To switch loyalty apps without losing regulars, keep the same reward, pick one simple way to carry progress over, and run both cards side by side for a short switch week. LoyalStamps has no bulk import, so staff carry balances over at the counter, one stamp at a time, as each regular joins the new card.

Before you switch: keep the deal the same

The fastest way to lose regulars is to change the reward and the app on the same day. If your old card was "10 coffees, 1 free", make the new one 10 stamps for a free coffee too. Change one thing at a time. If you want a new reward later, change it a month after the switch, with notice.

Step 1: Choose how to carry progress over

LoyalStamps has no import tool and no connection to other loyalty apps, so balances move by hand. Pick one of these and use it for everyone:

  • Match it exactly. The customer shows their old card or app, and staff add the same number of stamps to the new card, one at a time. Fairest, slightly slower at the counter.
  • Round it up. Anyone with progress on the old card gets a set head start, for example three stamps. Quick, generous, and easy to explain.
  • Finish the old card first. Customers keep using the old card until it is full, then start the new one. Nothing to convert, but you run two cards for a while.

Repeat stamping carries over progress, so matching a balance is just a few approvals in the vendor app.

Step 2: Convert points to stamps, if you are leaving a points app

Stamps and points do not line up neatly, so set one rule and write it down. For example, if your old program gave a reward at 100 points and your new card gives the same reward at 10 stamps, then every 10 points becomes one stamp (example numbers). Round in the customer's favour. For the wider differences, see stamp card vs points.

Step 3: Tell customers before switch week

  • A sign at the counter a week before: "New stamp card from [date]. Your progress comes with you."
  • A line from staff at every sale: "We're moving to a phone stamp card next week. Bring your old card and we'll carry it over."
  • A short post on your socials, without the QR code itself.

Ready-made lines are in loyalty card wording.

Step 4: Run switch week

  1. Put the new QR sign up next to the register.
  2. As each regular pays, ask them to scan and join.
  3. Carry over their progress using your Step 1 rule.
  4. Mark or collect the old card so it cannot be used twice.
  5. Keep a short note of who you have moved over, if your old system has no way to close a card.

Step 5: Retire the old program

Once most regulars have moved, set a final date for the old card and say so on the sign. Keep honouring old full cards for a fair while after. Cancel the old app's billing only after that date.

Notes for common switches

What not to do

  • Do not change the reward during the switch.
  • Do not post the new QR online to speed things up. Stamps should only happen at the counter.
  • Do not cancel the old program before regulars have had a fair chance to move.

What it costs

Vendor Pro is $10 a month or $100 a year after a 7-day free trial, with no credit card needed to start. One plan covers several locations. If the trial ends before you pay, your customers keep their cards and only the vendor app is locked until you subscribe. Details are on the pricing page.

Related guides

Replace paper stamp cards · Square Loyalty alternative · FiveStars alternative · Stamp Me alternative · LoyalStamps alternatives · Loyalty card wording

Switching loyalty apps FAQ

How do I switch loyalty apps without losing customers?

To switch loyalty apps without losing regulars, keep the same reward, pick one simple way to carry progress over, and run both cards side by side for a short switch week. LoyalStamps has no bulk import, so staff carry balances over at the counter, one stamp at a time, as each regular joins the new card.

Can I import customers or balances into LoyalStamps?

No. LoyalStamps has no import tool and no connection to other loyalty apps or POS systems. Staff carry progress over at the counter, adding stamps one at a time as each regular joins.

How do I convert loyalty points to stamps?

Set one rule based on the reward. If 100 points used to earn the same reward your new card gives at 10 stamps, every 10 points becomes one stamp. Round in the customer's favour and write the rule on your sign.

How long should I run both programs?

Long enough for regulars to visit at least once or twice. For a daily coffee shop that may be a week or two; for a salon with monthly visits it may be two or three months.

Should I change the reward when I switch apps?

Not at the same time. Keep the same deal during the switch so regulars only have one new thing to learn. Change the reward later, with notice.

What do I tell customers about the switch?

Keep it short: a new stamp card is coming, their progress comes with them, and they just scan at the counter. A sign, a line from staff at every sale, and a social post are enough.

Do customers need to download an app for LoyalStamps?

No. Customers scan your QR with their phone camera and keep a web card with just an email. The free LoyalStamps app is optional.

How much does LoyalStamps cost?

Vendor Pro is $10 a month or $100 a year after a 7-day free trial, with no credit card needed to start. One plan covers several locations. If the trial ends unpaid, customers keep their cards and only the vendor app is locked until you subscribe.

Ready to move your regulars over?

Start a 7-day free trial at store.loyalstamps.com. No credit card required.

Start your 7-day free trial